Expanding Marshmallows – structuring science learning around a discrepant event

I wrote an earlier post about the use of discrepant events in science teaching. One of the example events I used was ‘Expanding Marshmallows’. The science concepts that primary students need to know for this experiment are: that solids, liquids and gases have observable properties and behave in different ways (specifically that air has mass and takes up space) and that different materials have different properties (Board of Studies NSW, 2012, p.70).

It is important to understand the alternative conceptions that students might hold about particular science concepts, to be able to target these appropriately. In reviewing the research regarding children’s prior understanding of the properties of solids, liquids and gases, there are studies that indicate that, of the three, gases are the least well understood by primary-aged students (Skamp, 2012, p.313; VDET, 2014a; VDET, 2014b).

Three beliefs that are commonly held by children are:

  1. Air is not matter – Contributing to this misconception are the properties associated with air – invisibility, odourlessness, temperature, and flow or movement (Skamp, 2012, p.313; VDET, 2014a). Research findings do differ on students’ understanding of whether air is a gas, although some research has indicated that students up to the age of 12 years old generally see gases as combustible and therefore dangerous, unlike air (Skamp, 2012, p.313).
  1. Air is weightless, does not take up space and cannot be captured – Tying into this belief that air is not matter is a commonly held belief (especially among younger students), that an empty container does not contain air (Skamp, 2012, p.313). In one study, only 22% of children aged 5-7 years old could identify that a container was filled with air (Krnel et al., 1998, p.268). Language use also plays a role here, as we tend to say idiomatically that a jar or container that has nothing in it is ‘empty’. This can cause confusion as children are “expected to grasp that although empty, they really contain air” (VDET, 2014a). For children who do understand that air takes up space, they will often still make a distinction between the air inside a container, and the air outside it (Krnel et al, 1998, p.269). As Krnel et al states “a frequent explanation is that air is one big bulk”, with one study revealing that 46% of children considered air to be a continuum (1998, p.269). Similarly, there appear to be some misconceptions regarding the weight of air, with many students believing it to be weightless (Driver in Krnel et al., 1998, p.269).
  2. The movement of air is similar to water – Some studies have revealed that children also often hold misconceptions about the movement of air. For example, in one study, 11- to 12-year old children thought that when gas was forced into a container, more air was found on the bottom (Lee in Krnel et al., 1998, p.269). This reveals their belief that air is not equally distributed and flows in a similar way to water.

How might students explain what is happening in this discrepant event?

  • You are pumping the marshmallows up
  • The container is special (it’s magic)
  • Marshmallows multiply when air is taken away
  • Some air gets stuck and blows them up like balloons
  • When you take away the pressure from the air, marshmallows grow to their full size
  • The air travelled through the marshmallows and puffed them up
  • Air can change and grow bigger
  • Letting the air back in squashes them from the outside.

 

Questioning sequence you could develop around this event

  1. Who can tell me what is in the container? – Pass around container, students can shake and have a look
  2. What do you think will happen when you remove the air from inside the container?
  3. Describe what happened. Why do you think this happened?
  4. Did anyone think the marshmallows would do something different?
  5. What is happening each time I pump?
  6. If air is being sucked out of the container, why do the marshmallows grow bigger?
  7. What does the experiment tell us about the air in the marshmallows and container then?
  8. What was happening when the marshmallows shrank back? Why?
  9. What if we did the same experiment but with no marshmallows – is air still being sucked out of the container?
  10. What if I put a gold coin in the container? What do you think will happen when I remove the air from inside the container? (Perform the experiment)
  11. Describe what happened. Why do you think this is?
  12. What does this mean about the different materials? Why do marshmallows increase in size and not the gold coins?
  13. Draw a diagram illustrating what is happening to the marshmallows and air as the marshmallows expand, and also when the air is let back in. Explain how this is different or the same to your original explanation.

References

Krnel, D, Watson, R, & Glazar, S (1998). ‘Survey of research related to the development of the concept of “matter”’, International Journal of Science Education, 20 pp 257-289.

NSW Board of Studies. (2012). Science K-10 syllabus. Sydney: NSW Board of Studies.

Skamp, K. (2012). Teaching Primary Science Constructively (4th Ed). South Melbourne: Cengage.

Victorian Department of Education and Training (VDET). (2014a). A Gas is Matter. Retrieved from http://www.education.vic.gov.au/school/teachers/teachingresources/discipline/science/continuum/Pages/gasmatter.aspx

Victorian Department of Education and Training (VDET). (2014b). Problems with Classifying Solids, Liquids and Gases. Retrieved from http://www.education.vic.gov.au/school/teachers/teachingresources/discipline/science/continuum/pages/classifying.aspx

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s